Demystifying torch.Tensor.reshape_as: When and How to Reshape Tensors in PyTorch

Purpose

• Offers a convenient way to ensure compatibility between tensors for operations.
• Maintains the underlying data and total number of elements.
• Reshapes a tensor (self) to match the shape of another tensor (other).

How it Works

1. • self: The tensor you want to reshape.
   • other: The tensor whose shape you want self to adopt.

2. Reshaping
   

   • reshape_as calculates the new dimensions for self based on other.sizes(). This method retrieves the sizes (number of elements in each dimension) of other.
   • It then creates a new view of self with the desired shape. A view refers to a different way of looking at the same underlying data, without actually copying the data.

Equivalent to reshape

• reshape_as is functionally equivalent to:

  self.reshape(other.sizes())
  

Efficiency

• If the total number of elements in self and other are compatible (i.e., the product of their elements is the same), reshape_as creates a view, which is a more efficient operation compared to creating a new tensor with reshape.

Example

import torch

# Create two tensors
tensor1 = torch.tensor([1, 2, 3, 4])  # Shape: [4]
tensor2 = torch.tensor([[5, 6], [7, 8]])  # Shape: [2, 2]

# Reshape tensor1 to match the shape of tensor2
reshaped_tensor = tensor1.reshape_as(tensor2)

print(reshaped_tensor)  # Output: tensor([[1, 2], [3, 4]])

Key Points

• Be mindful of potential errors if the total number of elements in self and other are not compatible.
• It's generally more efficient than reshape if the total number of elements aligns.
• Use reshape_as when you want to ensure two tensors have the same shape for operations.

---

Example 1: Reshaping with Unequal Leading Dimensions

This example demonstrates reshaping when the leading dimensions of the tensors differ:

import torch

tensor1 = torch.arange(10)  # Shape: [10]
tensor2 = torch.arange(16).reshape(2, 8)  # Shape: [2, 8]

# Reshape tensor1 to match the first dimension of tensor2 (creating a new row)
reshaped_tensor = tensor1.reshape_as(tensor2[:, 0])  # Select the first column of tensor2

print(reshaped_tensor)  # Output: tensor([[0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7], [8, 9]])

Here, tensor1 is reshaped to have the same number of elements in the first dimension (2) as the first column of tensor2. The remaining elements of tensor1 fill the second dimension.

Example 2: Handling Incompatible Total Elements

This example showcases what happens when the total number of elements is incompatible:

import torch

tensor1 = torch.arange(6)  # Shape: [6]
tensor2 = torch.arange(12).reshape(3, 4)  # Shape: [3, 4]

try:
  reshaped_tensor = tensor1.reshape_as(tensor2)
except RuntimeError as e:
  print("Error:", e)

This code will raise a RuntimeError because tensor1 has 6 elements, while tensor2 has 12. Reshaping is not possible without modifying the data or creating a new tensor with padding.

Example 3: Reshaping with -1

This example utilizes the -1 placeholder in reshape_as:

import torch

tensor1 = torch.arange(12).reshape(3, 4)  # Shape: [3, 4]
tensor2 = torch.arange(6)  # Shape: [6]

# Reshape tensor1 such that the first dimension matches tensor2 and
# infer the second dimension based on the remaining elements
reshaped_tensor = tensor1.reshape_as(tensor2[:, None])  # Add a new dimension with size 1

print(reshaped_tensor)  # Output: tensor([[0, 1, 2], [3, 4, 5], [6, 7, 8]])

---

1. • This is the most direct alternative. It allows you to specify the desired shape for the reshaped tensor.
   • Syntax: tensor.reshape(new_shape)
   • Use this if you know the exact shape you want for the output tensor, regardless of another tensor's shape.

2. torch.view
   

   • Creates a new view of the underlying data with the specified shape, if possible.
   • Syntax: tensor.view(new_shape)
   • Use this when you want to ensure the total number of elements in the original and reshaped tensors remain the same. It's generally more memory-efficient than reshape if the view is possible.

3. Manual Reshaping with Indexing
   

   • This approach involves using advanced indexing techniques to create the desired shape.
   • Syntax: reshaped_tensor = original_tensor[new_indexing] (specific indexing depends on the desired shape)
   • Use this if you have specific indexing requirements or need more control over the reshaping process. This can be less efficient for simple reshaping tasks.

4. torch.repeat (for Repetition)
   

   • Creates a new tensor by repeating the input tensor a specified number of times along each dimension.
   • Syntax: repeated_tensor = original_tensor.repeat(repeats)
   • Use this if you want to create a new tensor by repeating the original tensor along certain dimensions.

Method	Description	Flexibility	Memory Efficiency
reshape_as	Reshapes based on another tensor's shape	Limited	Efficient if view
reshape	Reshapes to a specified shape	High	Less efficient
view	Creates a view with a new shape (if possible)	High	Efficient if view
Manual Reshaping	Reshapes using advanced indexing techniques	High	Varies
torch.repeat	Repeats the tensor along specified dimensions	Limited	Less efficient

Choosing the Right Alternative

• Use torch.repeat for specific repetition requirements.
• For memory efficiency when maintaining the same elements, consider view if applicable.
• If you need more control over the reshaping process or cannot guarantee compatible element counts, use reshape or manual reshaping.
• For simple reshaping based on another tensor's shape, reshape_as is a convenient choice.