Understanding torch.Tensor.to_dense() and Its Alternatives

Purpose

• Dense tensors, on the other hand, store all elements explicitly, regardless of their value.
• Sparse tensors represent data where most elements are zero. They store only the non-zero elements and their corresponding indices, making them memory-efficient for large datasets with many zeros.
• Converts a sparse tensor in PyTorch to a dense (strided) tensor.

Functionality

• Checks the layout of the input tensor (self):
  • If it's already a strided tensor (dense), to_dense() simply returns the tensor itself (self) as it's already in the desired format.
  • If it's a sparse tensor (e.g., torch.sparse_coo), to_dense() creates a new strided tensor with the same data and dimensions as the sparse tensor. This new tensor will have all elements explicitly stored, including zeros.

Optional Argument

• masked_grad (boolean, default=True):
  • Only relevant during backpropagation (gradient calculation) when converting from a sparse tensor.
  • If True (default), the gradient of the dense tensor is masked during backpropagation to match the sparsity pattern of the original sparse tensor. This ensures that gradients are only computed for non-zero elements in the sparse tensor.
  • If False, the gradient of the dense tensor is not masked, but this might not be memory-efficient or necessary depending on your use case.

Example

import torch

# Create a sparse tensor
i = torch.tensor([0, 1, 2])
v = torch.tensor([3, 1, 4])
s = torch.sparse_coo_tensor(i, v, size=(3, 4))  # Example sparse tensor

# Convert to dense tensor
dense_tensor = s.to_dense()

print(dense_tensor)
# Output (assuming i, v, and size values above):
# tensor([[3, 0, 0, 0],
#        [1, 0, 0, 0],
#        [0, 0, 4, 0]])

• The to_dense() method is currently deprecated in PyTorch (as of version 1.13). While it still works in most cases, it's recommended to explicitly convert to a dense tensor before performing operations that require it. This might involve using .to_dense() for now, but future PyTorch versions might introduce alternative methods.
• If you only need to perform certain operations on the sparse tensor that are compatible with sparse tensors, you might not need to convert to dense at all. PyTorch supports some operations directly on sparse tensors.
• Converting a large sparse tensor to a dense tensor can be memory-intensive, so use it judiciously if memory is a concern.

---

Sparse Tensor Addition with Conversion

This example shows adding a sparse tensor to a dense tensor and then converting the result to dense for further operations:

import torch

# Sparse tensor
s = torch.sparse_coo_tensor([[0, 1], [1, 2]], [4, 2], size=(3, 3))

# Dense tensor
d = torch.tensor([[1, 0, 0], [0, 1, 0], [0, 0, 1]])

# Addition (result is sparse)
result_sparse = d + s

# Convert to dense for further use (e.g., printing or other operations)
result_dense = result_sparse.to_dense()

print(result_dense)
# Output:
# tensor([[5, 0, 0],
#        [0, 3, 0],
#        [0, 0, 2]])

Backpropagation with masked_grad

This example demonstrates using masked_grad=False during backpropagation. Note that this might not be memory-efficient depending on your use case:

import torch

# Sparse tensor
s = torch.sparse_coo_tensor([[0]], [2], size=(2, 2))  # Sparse tensor with single non-zero element

# Define a function to operate on the sparse tensor
def my_func(x):
  return x * 2

# Apply the function with masking disabled
dense_tensor = s.to_dense(masked_grad=False)  # Disable masking
output = my_func(dense_tensor)

# Backpropagation (gradients will be computed for all elements)
output.backward()

# Print gradients (might include non-zero gradients for zero elements)
print(s.grad)

Using Dense Tensors as-is (Avoiding Conversion)

This example highlights that if operations are compatible with sparse tensors, conversion might not be necessary:

import torch

# Sparse tensor
s = torch.sparse_coo_tensor([[0, 1], [1, 2]], [4, 2], size=(3, 3))

# Element-wise multiplication (compatible with sparse tensors)
result_sparse = s * torch.tensor([[2, 0, 0], [0, 2, 0], [0, 0, 2]])

print(result_sparse)
# Output (sparse tensor with updated values):
# torch.sparse_coo(indices=tensor([[0, 1], [1, 2]]), values=tensor([8, 4]), size=(3, 3))

---

Explicit Conversion to Strided (Dense) Tensors

• This is the most straightforward approach. If you know you need a dense tensor for further operations, explicitly convert the sparse tensor using:

  dense_tensor = sparse_tensor.to_strided()  # This replaces the deprecated to_dense()
  

Operations on Sparse Tensors (if applicable)

• PyTorch supports many operations directly on sparse tensors. Check the PyTorch documentation for supported operations on sparse tensors. If the operations you need are supported, you may not need to convert to a dense tensor at all.

Sparse-Dense Hybrid Tensors (Future PyTorch Versions)

Alternative	Description
Explicit Conversion to Strided (Dense) Tensors	Convert the entire sparse tensor to a dense tensor.
Operations on Sparse Tensors (if applicable)	If your operations are supported, use them directly on the sparse tensor.
Sparse-Dense Hybrid Tensors (Future PyTorch)	(Not yet available) Represent tensors with some sparse and some dense dimensions.

When choosing an alternative, consider:

• PyTorch Version
  Be aware of the features available in your current PyTorch version. Sparse-dense hybrid tensors might become a viable option in future versions.
• Operations Required
  If your operations are compatible with sparse tensors (option 2), that's the most efficient approach.
• Memory Constraints
  Converting to a dense tensor can be memory-intensive. If memory is a concern, explore options 2 or 3 (if available).