Understanding Positive Tensors in PyTorch: Alternatives to a Missing Method

1. • Tensors are the fundamental data structure in PyTorch. They are like multi-dimensional arrays that can hold various data types (numbers, text, etc.).

2. Checking for Positive Values
   

   • There are several ways to check if a tensor contains positive values:
     • torch.gt(tensor, 0)
       This function returns a new tensor with True for elements greater than 0 and False otherwise.
     • tensor.where(tensor > 0, other)
       This performs element-wise comparison. You can replace "other" with a value to assign to non-positive elements.

3. Missing torch.Tensor.positive Method
   

   • PyTorch doesn't have a built-in torch.Tensor.positive method that directly returns a positive version of the tensor.

For achieving a positive tensor, you can use element-wise operations like:

• torch.abs(tensor)
  This creates a new tensor with the absolute values of all elements in the original tensor.

---

Checking for Positive Values

import torch

# Create a sample tensor
tensor = torch.tensor([-2, 1.5, 0, 4.2])

# Check for elements greater than 0 using torch.gt
is_positive = torch.gt(tensor, 0)
print(is_positive)  # Output: tensor([False,  True, False,  True])

# Check for elements greater than 0 with element-wise comparison
positive_elements = tensor.where(tensor > 0, -1)  # Replace non-positive with -1 (optional)
print(positive_elements)  # Output: tensor([ -1.,  1.5,  -1.,  4.2])

Creating a Positive Tensor

a) Using torch.abs

positive_tensor = torch.abs(tensor)
print(positive_tensor)  # Output: tensor([2., 1.5, 0., 4.2])

This creates a new tensor with all elements converted to their absolute values (positive).

positive_tensor = tensor[tensor > 0]
print(positive_tensor)  # Output: tensor([ 1.5,  4.2])

---

1. • torch.gt(tensor, 0)
     This remains the best option for simply checking which elements are positive. It returns a boolean tensor indicating True for positive values and False otherwise.

2. Creating a Positive-like Tensor
   

   • torch.abs(tensor)
     This creates a new tensor with the absolute values of all elements. It's useful when you need all values to be non-negative, regardless of their original sign.
   • tensor[tensor > 0]
     This approach creates a new tensor containing only the positive elements from the original tensor. It's suitable when you want to work exclusively with the positive portion.
   • torch.clamp(tensor, min=0, max=float('inf'))
     This method clamps all elements between a minimum (0 in this case) and a maximum value (positive infinity). It allows you to set a lower bound for your "positive-like" tensor.

• Want elements to be non-negative with a lower bound
  Use torch.clamp(tensor, min=0, max=float('inf'))
• Want only positive elements
  Use tensor[tensor > 0]
• Need absolute values (non-negative)
  Use torch.abs(tensor)
• Check for positive elements
  Use torch.gt(tensor, 0)