Understanding Logical vs. Visual Positions in Qt Widgets with QStyle::visualPos()

QStyle::visualPos()

In Qt Widgets, QStyle::visualPos() is a function provided by the QStyle class that plays a crucial role in translating between a widget's logical position (its position within its own coordinate system) and its visual position (its position on the screen relative to the widget's top-left corner). This transformation is essential for rendering widgets correctly and ensuring their appearance aligns with the platform's native look and feel.

Understanding Logical vs. Visual Positions

• Visual Position
  This is the widget's actual position on the screen, taking into account factors like margins, borders, and the widget's style. It's calculated by applying transformations defined by the widget's style to the logical position.
• Logical Position
  This refers to a widget's position within its own coordinate system, which typically starts at (0, 0) in the widget's top-left corner. This position is independent of the widget's actual location on the screen.

How QStyle::visualPos() Works

When you call QStyle::visualPos() on a style object (QStyle* style), you pass it a QPoint that represents the logical position within the widget. The QStyle class then applies any necessary style-specific adjustments to convert it into the corresponding visual position. These adjustments might involve:

• Alignment
  Adjusting the position based on the widget's alignment settings (e.g., centered, top-left, etc.).
• Borders
  Taking into account the width and style of borders defined by the style.
• Margins
  Adding margins specified by the style around the widget.

Example Usage

#include <QApplication>
#QWidget *widget = new QWidget;
QStyle *style = widget->style(); // Get the widget's style object

QPoint logicalPos(10, 20); // Logical position within the widget
QPoint visualPos = style->visualPos(QStyle::SubControl::SC_None, widget, logicalPos);

// visualPos now holds the widget's actual on-screen position based on style adjustments

In this example, logicalPos represents a point within the widget's coordinate system. The visualPos obtained after calling QStyle::visualPos() will reflect the actual on-screen position, taking into account any style-related adjustments defined by the widget's style object (style).

• By providing the QStyle object and the logical position, QStyle::visualPos() handles the style-specific transformations.
• It's essential for accurate rendering, especially when dealing with margins, borders, and alignment.
• QStyle::visualPos() is primarily used for drawing and styling widgets correctly, ensuring they adhere to the platform's native look and feel.

---

Example 1: Drawing a Button with Styled Margin

#include <QApplication>
#include <QPushButton>
#include <QStylePainter>

class MyButton : public QPushButton {
    void paintEvent(QPaintEvent *event) override {
        QStylePainter painter(this); // Use the widget's style painter
        QStyleOptionButton option;
        option.initFrom(this); // Initialize with widget's state
        const QRect rect = style()->subControlRect(QStyle::ControlElement::CE_PushButton, &option, this);

        // Draw button content (text, icon, etc.) here...

        // Draw a styled margin around the button
        QPoint topLeft = style()->visualPos(QStyle::SubControl::SC_None, this, rect.topLeft());
        QPoint bottomRight = style()->visualPos(QStyle::SubControl::SC_None, this, rect.bottomRight());
        QRect marginRect(topLeft, bottomRight);
        painter.fillRect(marginRect, Qt::lightGray); // Draw a light gray margin

        QPushButton::paintEvent(event); // Call base class paintEvent for default drawing
    }
};

int main(int argc, char *argv[]) {
    QApplication app(argc, argv);
    MyButton button("Styled Button");
    button.show();
    return app.exec();
}

In this example, MyButton overrides the paintEvent to draw a styled margin around the button using QStyle::visualPos(). It gets the button's rectangle using subControlRect() and then calculates the visual top-left and bottom-right corners using visualPos(). This allows for drawing the margin rectangle with the correct positioning based on the style's margin settings.

Example 2: Customizing Widget Alignment

#include <QApplication>
#include <QWidget>
#include <QHBoxLayout>

class CustomWidget : public QWidget {
public:
    CustomWidget(QWidget *parent = nullptr) : QWidget(parent) {
        QHBoxLayout *layout = new QHBoxLayout(this);
        layout->setMargin(0); // Remove default margin

        QLabel *label1 = new QLabel("Label 1");
        QLabel *label2 = new QLabel("Label 2 (Right-Aligned)");

        layout->addWidget(label1);
        layout->addWidget(label2, Qt::AlignRight); // Set right alignment for label2
    }

    void paintEvent(QPaintEvent *event) override {
        QWidget::paintEvent(event);

        // Optionally customize alignment based on style
        QStyle *style = this->style();
        QLabel *rightAlignedLabel = findChild<QLabel*>("Label 2");

        // Get the logical and visual rectangles for the right-aligned label
        QRect logicalRect = rightAlignedLabel->geometry();
        QPoint topLeft = style()->visualPos(QStyle::SubControl::SC_None, this, logicalRect.topLeft());
        QPoint bottomRight = style()->visualPos(QStyle::SubControl::SC_None, this, logicalRect.bottomRight());
        QRect visualRect(topLeft, bottomRight);

        // You could further adjust visualRect based on style-specific alignment rules
    }
};

int main(int argc, char *argv[]) {
    QApplication app(argc, argv);
    CustomWidget widget;
    widget.show();
    return app.exec();
}

This example demonstrates customizing widget alignment within a layout. While the layout sets Qt::AlignRight for the second label, you might want to fine-tune the alignment based on the style's specific rules. In the paintEvent, visualPos() is used to get the visual rectangle of the right-aligned label. You could then perform additional adjustments to the visual rectangle if needed to achieve the desired alignment according to the style.

---

style()->subControlRect(controlElement, option, widget)

• It's more efficient for common control elements as it avoids the overhead of a separate calculation.
• This function directly retrieves the rectangle representing the visual position of a specific control element within a widget, taking into account style-related adjustments.

Example

QRect buttonRect = style()->subControlRect(QStyle::ControlElement::CE_PushButton, &option, this);

Manual Calculations with Style Information

• This approach is generally less maintainable and susceptible to style changes.
• If you have a deep understanding of the widget's style and its margin/border properties, you can potentially calculate the visual position manually.

Example

// Assuming a 5-pixel margin on all sides defined by the style
QPoint topLeft = widget->geometry().topLeft() + QPoint(5, 5);
QRect visualRect(topLeft, widget->geometry().bottomRight() - QPoint(10, 10));

Custom Style Subclasses

• This approach requires in-depth knowledge of Qt's style system and is typically used for complex scenarios.
• For highly customized widgets or to override specific style calculations, you can create a subclass of QStyle.

• Manual calculations or custom styles should generally be reserved for very specific situations where the built-in methods don't meet your needs.
• If performance is a critical concern and you're dealing with common control elements, subControlRect() might be a more efficient alternative.
• In most cases, QStyle::visualPos() is the preferred option as it provides a convenient and style-aware way to handle logical-to-visual position conversion.