Qt Widgets: Beyond the Standard Menu Bar - Alternatives to QMainWindow::setMenuWidget()

Purpose

• The menu bar is typically positioned horizontally at the top of the window and contains menus that provide access to various application functionalities.
• In Qt applications that utilize QMainWindow, this function allows you to establish a custom menu bar for your main window.

Function Breakdown

• setMenuWidget(): This is the actual function name. It takes a single argument, a pointer to a QWidget object.
• QMainWindow
  : This part signifies that the function belongs to the QMainWindow class, which is the foundation for creating main windows in Qt Widgets applications.

Arguments

• QWidget* menuBar: This argument represents the widget that will function as the menu bar. It's common practice to create a QMenuBar object for this purpose, as it's specifically designed to hold menus and their actions. However, you're not restricted to QMenuBar and could conceivably employ another QWidget subclass if it fulfills your specific menu bar requirements.

Ownership Transfer

• It's crucial to remember that QMainWindow takes ownership of the QWidget pointer you pass to setMenuWidget(). This implies that QMainWindow will manage the memory for that widget and delete it when it's no longer required.

#include <QApplication>
#include <QMainWindow>
#include <QMenuBar>
#include <QMenu>
#include <QAction>

int main(int argc, char *argv[]) {
    QApplication app(argc, argv);

    // Create the main window
    QMainWindow window;

    // Create a menu bar
    QMenuBar* menuBar = new QMenuBar;

    // Create a menu and add some actions
    QMenu* fileMenu = new QMenu("File");
    fileMenu->addAction("Open");
    fileMenu->addAction("Save");
    fileMenu->addAction("Exit");

    // Add the menu to the menu bar
    menuBar->addMenu(fileMenu);

    // Set the menu bar for the main window
    window.setMenuWidget(menuBar);

    window.show();

    return app.exec();
}

1. Necessary Qt Widgets headers are included.
2. A QApplication object is created to manage the application's event loop.
3. A QMainWindow object is instantiated to serve as the main window.
4. A QMenuBar object is created using new to construct the menu bar widget.
5. A QMenu object, named fileMenu, is created using new to represent a specific menu within the menu bar. Actions ("Open", "Save", and "Exit") are added to this menu using addAction().
6. The fileMenu is incorporated into the menuBar using addMenu().
7. The setMenuWidget() function is called on window, passing the menuBar as the argument. This establishes menuBar as the custom menu bar for the main window.
8. The main window is displayed using show().
9. The application's event loop is started using app.exec().

---

Using a Stacked Widget as a Menu Bar

While QMenuBar is the typical choice, you can create more complex menu layouts using other widgets like QStackedWidget. This example creates a menu with two tabs, "File" and "Edit":

#include <QApplication>
#include <QMainWindow>
#include <QStackedWidget>
#include <QMenuBar>
#include <QMenu>
#include <QAction>

int main(int argc, char *argv[]) {
    QApplication app(argc, argv);

    // Create the main window
    QMainWindow window;

    // Create a stacked widget for the menu bar
    QStackedWidget* menuBar = new QStackedWidget;

    // Create menus for each tab
    QMenu* fileMenu = new QMenu("File");
    fileMenu->addAction("Open");
    fileMenu->addAction("Save");
    fileMenu->addAction("Exit");

    QMenu* editMenu = new QMenu("Edit");
    editMenu->addAction("Undo");
    editMenu->addAction("Redo");
    editMenu->addAction("Cut");

    // Add menus to the stacked widget
    menuBar->addWidget(fileMenu);
    menuBar->addWidget(editMenu);

    // Set the stacked widget as the menu bar
    window.setMenuWidget(menuBar);

    // Create buttons to switch between tabs
    QPushButton* fileButton = new QPushButton("File");
    QPushButton* editButton = new QPushButton("Edit");

    // Connect buttons to stacked widget
    connect(fileButton, &QPushButton::clicked, menuBar, [menuBar] { menuBar->setCurrentIndex(0); });
    connect(editButton, &QPushButton::clicked, menuBar, [menuBar] { menuBar->setCurrentIndex(1); });

    // Add buttons to a toolbar
    QHBoxLayout* toolbarLayout = new QHBoxLayout;
    toolbarLayout->addWidget(fileButton);
    toolbarLayout->addWidget(editButton);
    QToolBar* toolbar = new QToolBar;
    toolbar->setLayout(toolbarLayout);
    window.addToolBar(Qt::ToolBarArea::TopToolBarArea, toolbar);

    window.show();

    return app.exec();
}

Creating a Menu Bar Programmatically

Instead of creating separate QMenu objects beforehand, you can construct them dynamically within setMenuWidget():

#include <QApplication>
#include <QMainWindow>
#include <QMenuBar>
#include <QMenu>
#include <QAction>

int main(int argc, char *argv[]) {
    QApplication app(argc, argv);

    // Create the main window
    QMainWindow window;

    // Create a menu bar
    QMenuBar* menuBar = new QMenuBar;

    // Create and add menus dynamically
    QMenu* fileMenu = menuBar->addMenu("File");
    fileMenu->addAction("Open");
    fileMenu->addAction("Save");
    fileMenu->addAction("Exit");

    QMenu* editMenu = menuBar->addMenu("Edit");
    editMenu->addAction("Undo");
    editMenu->addAction("Redo");
    editMenu->addAction("Cut");

    // Set the menu bar for the main window
    window.setMenuWidget(menuBar);

    window.show();

    return app.exec();
}

---

Using QToolBar

• Toolbars are often positioned horizontally at the top of the window, similar to menu bars.
• You can add QAction objects to the toolbar, which connect to slots in your code for functionality execution.
• If you prefer a simpler approach with fewer nested menus, consider using a QToolBar. It allows displaying icons or text buttons that represent actions within the application.

Customizing the Title Bar

• This approach is less conventional for menu structures but might be suitable for minimal applications with simple actions.
• Use Qt Stylesheets or custom widgets to modify the title bar's appearance and add buttons or interactive elements.
• While not a direct replacement, you can customize the title bar of your QMainWindow to incorporate basic functionalities.

Method	Pros	Cons
QMainWindow::setMenuWidget()	Standard approach for complex menus	Limited visual customization
QToolBar	Simpler, icon-based approach	Fewer nesting options for complex functionalities
Custom Title Bar	Minimalistic, non-standard approach	Limited functionality, might not be intuitive

• Customizing the title bar is a niche approach best suited for very specific use cases where a standard menu bar is not necessary.
• For simpler applications with a few core actions, a QToolBar provides a more streamlined experience.
• If you need a traditional menu bar with cascading menus and submenus, QMainWindow::setMenuWidget() is the recommended choice.