Exploring Alternatives to torch.distributions.independent.Independent.variance

Understanding Independent Distribution

• It doesn't fundamentally change the underlying probabilistic behavior of the base distribution.
• This is primarily used to reshape the output of the log_prob method, making it compatible with certain use cases, such as working with diagonal vs. full covariance matrices.
• The Independent class in torch.distributions creates a new distribution by reinterpreting a portion of the batch dimensions of a base distribution as event dimensions.

variance Property

• Since Independent doesn't modify the base distribution's variance, the variance of the resulting distribution remains the same.
• In other words, it retrieves the variance of the base distribution, which represents the spread or squared deviation of its samples from the mean.
• The variance property of the Independent class simply delegates the calculation to the base_dist.variance.

Code Breakdown (Illustrative Example)

import torch
from torch.distributions import Independent, Normal

# Create a base Normal distribution with batch_shape=[2] and event_shape=[]
base_dist = Normal(loc=torch.zeros(2), scale=torch.ones(2))  # 2 independent normal distributions

# Wrap it in Independent to reinterpret 1 batch dimension as event dimension
independent_dist = Independent(base_dist, reinterpreted_batch_ndims=1)

# Calculate variance (same as base distribution's variance)
variance = independent_dist.variance

print("Base distribution variance:", base_dist.variance)
print("Independent distribution variance:", variance)

Key Points

• Variance is inherited from the base distribution.
• Independent reshapes the output, not the distribution itself.

• This property and methods like mean, mode, sample, and rsample also inherit their behavior from the base distribution.
• The reinterpreted_batch_ndims parameter in Independent controls how many batch dimensions are reinterpreted as event dimensions.

---

Example 1: Independent Bernoulli Distribution with Variance Calculation

import torch
from torch.distributions import Independent, Bernoulli

# Create a base Bernoulli distribution with batch_shape=[3, 2]
base_dist = Bernoulli(probs=torch.tensor([[0.3, 0.7], [0.8, 0.2], [0.5, 0.5]]))

# Wrap it in Independent to interpret the last dimension as independent events
independent_dist = Independent(base_dist, reinterpreted_batch_ndims=1)

# Calculate variance (element-wise for each independent Bernoulli)
variance = independent_dist.variance

print("Base distribution variance:", base_dist.variance)  # Will print all ones (variance of Bernoulli is p * (1 - p))
print("Independent distribution variance:", variance)

In this example, we create a base Bernoulli distribution with a batch shape of [3, 2], meaning we have 3 independent Bernoulli distributions, each with two possible outcomes (success or failure). By wrapping it in Independent and setting reinterpreted_batch_ndims=1, we treat the last dimension (2) as independent events within each batch element. The variance calculation remains element-wise, reflecting the variance of each Bernoulli distribution (product of probability and its complement).

Example 2: Independent Multivariate Normal with Variance Calculation

import torch
from torch.distributions import Independent, MultivariateNormal

# Create a base MultivariateNormal distribution with batch_shape=[2] and event_shape=[3]
loc = torch.zeros(2, 3)
scale_tril = torch.diag(torch.ones(2, 3))  # Lower triangular matrix for covariance
base_dist = MultivariateNormal(loc=loc, scale_tril=scale_tril)

# Wrap it in Independent to keep batch dimension and treat each data point as independent
independent_dist = Independent(base_dist, reinterpreted_batch_ndims=0)

# Calculate variance (3D tensor, same shape as base distribution's variance)
variance = independent_dist.variance

print("Base distribution variance shape:", base_dist.variance.shape)
print("Independent distribution variance shape:", variance.shape)

# Access variance for a specific data point
data_point = torch.tensor([1.0, 2.0, 3.0])
data_point_variance = independent_dist.variance[0]  # Access variance for the first batch element

print("Variance of first data point:", data_point_variance)

Here, we create a MultivariateNormal distribution with a batch shape of [2] and an event shape of [3], representing two independent 3-dimensional normal distributions. Independent is used to maintain the batch dimension, treating each data point (entire 3D vector) as an independent event. The variance calculation results in a 3D tensor with the same shape as the base distribution's variance, holding the variances for each dimension within each data point. You can then access the variance for a specific data point by indexing into the batch dimension of the variance tensor.

---

Accessing Base Distribution's Variance Directly

If you only need the variance of the base distribution without the reshaping behavior of Independent, you can access it directly from the base distribution object:

base_dist = ...  # Your base distribution (e.g., Normal, Bernoulli, etc.)
variance = base_dist.variance

This approach is simpler and avoids the overhead of creating an Independent wrapper.

Manual Calculation

For more control or for distributions that don't have a built-in variance property, you can calculate the variance yourself. The specific formula depends on the distribution type. Some common examples:

• Binomial
  variance = n * p * (1 - p) (n is the number of trials, p is the probability of success)
• Bernoulli
  variance = probs * (1 - probs) (product of probability and its complement)
• Normal
  `variance = scale** (square of the scale parameter)

Using torch.var Function

The torch.var function can be used to calculate the variance of a tensor, but it requires careful handling:

samples = base_dist.sample(sample_shape)  # Sample from the base distribution
variance = torch.var(samples)

This approach works well if you already have samples from the base distribution. However, it's important to consider the number of samples and potential biases in the variance estimate.

Choosing the Right Alternative

The best alternative depends on your specific context:

• torch.var is useful for variance estimation from samples, but sample size and bias considerations are crucial.
• Manual calculation is suitable if you need more control or the base distribution lacks a variance property.
• Direct access is preferred when you only need the base distribution's variance.