Understanding Memory Movement in C++ Strings: std::memmove vs. std::copy and std::string Functions

What is std::memmove?

std::memmove is a function from the C++ standard library <cstring> header. It's used to copy a block of memory from one location to another. Unlike its counterpart std::memcpy, std::memmove can handle situations where the source and destination regions overlap in memory.

Why is it relevant to Strings?

C++ strings are typically implemented as null-terminated character arrays. When you manipulate strings, you might need to move parts of the character array around. std::memmove becomes crucial when these string manipulations involve overlapping memory regions.

How does it work with Overlapping Memory?

Imagine you have a string "hello" and want to remove the 'l'. Naively, you might shift the characters left one position. But if you use std::memcpy, it might corrupt the data because it copies blindly from source to destination.

std::memmove handles this by working as if it uses a temporary buffer. It:

1. Checks if the source and destination overlap.
2. If they do, it copies characters in a safe order:
   • If the source precedes the destination, it copies from beginning to end.
   • If the destination precedes the source, it copies from end to beginning.
3. This ensures data integrity during the overlap.

Important Note

While std::memmove is conceptually described as using a temporary buffer, most implementations optimize it to avoid actual extra memory allocation. They might copy in the safe direction directly.

Use Cases for std::memmove with Strings

• Reversing a string (treated as a character array).
• Inserting characters within a string (shifting existing characters).
• Removing characters from within a string.

Why not std::string member functions?

The standard C++ string class (std::string) offers member functions for most string manipulations. These functions are generally safer and more convenient to use than directly manipulating the underlying character array. However, in specific scenarios where you need fine-grained control over memory movement, std::memmove can be a valuable tool.

• For most string manipulations, prefer the member functions of std::string.
• Use std::memmove with caution, as it can lead to unexpected behavior if not used correctly.

---

Removing a Character

#include <iostream>
#include <cstring>

int main() {
  char str[] = "hello";

  // Remove the 'l' character
  int index = 3;  // Index of character to remove

  // Shift characters using std::memmove (safer for overlapping memory)
  std::memmove(str + index, str + index + 1, strlen(str) - index);

  // Shorten the string by 1 character (optional)
  str[strlen(str) - 1] = '\0';

  std::cout << str << std::endl;  // Output: "heo"
  return 0;
}

Inserting a Character

#include <iostream>
#include <cstring>

int main() {
  char str[20] = "world";

  // Insert '!' at index 3 (before 'r')
  int index = 3;
  char char_to_insert = '!';

  // Make space for the new character
  std::memmove(str + index + 1, str + index, strlen(str) - index);

  // Insert the character
  str[index] = char_to_insert;

  std::cout << str << std::endl;  // Output: "wor!ld"
  return 0;
}

Reversing a String (using memmove on character array)

#include <iostream>
#include <cstring>

int main() {
  char str[] = "hello";

  int len = strlen(str);

  // Reverse the string using std::memmove
  for (int i = 0; i < len / 2; i++) {
    std::memmove(str + i, str + len - i - 1, 1);
  }

  std::cout << str << std::endl;  // Output: "olleh"
  return 0;
}

• Remember, std::string offers member functions for most common string operations, which are generally preferred for readability and safety.
• These examples demonstrate how std::memmove allows safe character manipulation even when memory regions overlap.

---

std::copy and std::copy_n

• They offer safer and more readable syntax compared to std::memmove.
• For trivially copyable types (like char in strings), they might internally call std::memmove for efficiency.
• They handle both overlapping and non-overlapping memory regions.
• These functions are part of the <algorithm> header and are generally preferred over std::memmove for most cases.

Example (Removing a Character)

#include <algorithm>
#include <iostream>
#include <cstring>

int main() {
  char str[] = "hello";
  int index = 3;  // Index of character to remove

  // Remove the 'l' character using std::copy
  std::copy(str + index + 1, str + strlen(str), str + index);

  // Shorten the string by 1 character (optional)
  str[strlen(str) - 1] = '\0';

  std::cout << str << std::endl;  // Output: "heo"
}

std::string member functions

• They handle operations like removing, inserting, and reversing characters without needing manual memory management.
• These functions are generally safer and more convenient than using raw character arrays and std::memmove.
• The C++ standard string class (std::string) offers a variety of member functions for string manipulation.

Example (Removing a Character)

#include <iostream>
#include <string>

int main() {
  std::string str = "hello";
  int index = 3;  // Index of character to remove

  // Remove the 'l' character using erase
  str.erase(index, 1);

  std::cout << str << std::endl;  // Output: "heo"
}

• Use std::memmove cautiously and only when necessary for specific scenarios where other options fall short.
• For most string manipulations, prioritize using the member functions of std::string for readability and safety.
• If you need fine-grained control over memory movement and are comfortable with raw character arrays, std::copy or std::copy_n can be safer alternatives to std::memmove.