Understanding PHP's xml_set_notation_decl_handler for XML Notation Processing

Purpose

• Notation declarations are part of the Document Type Definition (DTD) and specify how external data (notations) should be processed by the parser.
• This function allows you to define a custom function that gets called whenever the XML parser encounters a notation declaration within an XML document.

Syntax

bool xml_set_notation_decl_handler(resource $parser, callable $handler);

Parameters

• $handler (required): A callable that specifies the function to be invoked when a notation declaration is found. This can be:
  • A string containing the name of an existing function.
  • An array containing an object reference and a method name (not currently supported).
• $parser (required): A resource handle representing the XML parser created using xml_parser_create().

Handler Function Signature

The custom function you provide ($handler) must have the following signature:

function handler(resource $parser, string $notationName, string $base, string $systemId, string $publicId): void;

• $publicId (string): The public identifier of the notation, if present.
• $systemId (string): The system identifier (URI) of the external data associated with the notation, if present.
• $base (string): Currently always an empty string (null in older PHP versions).
• $notationName (string): The name assigned to the notation in the declaration.
• $parser: The same XML parser resource as the first parameter of xml_set_notation_decl_handler.

Return Value

• xml_set_notation_decl_handler returns TRUE on success, indicating that the handler was set up correctly.

How It Works

1. You call xml_set_notation_decl_handler to associate your custom handler function with the XML parser.
2. As the parser processes the XML document, it encounters notation declarations.
3. For each notation declaration, it invokes your handler function, passing the relevant information:
   • $notationName: The name of the notation.
   • $base: Currently always an empty string.
   • $systemId (optional): The URI of the external data, if specified.
   • $publicId (optional): The public identifier of the notation, if provided.
4. Within your handler function, you can perform custom actions based on the notation information. You can:
   • Validate the notation declaration.
   • Register the notation for later processing.
   • Ignore the declaration if it's not relevant to your application.

Example

<?php
$parser = xml_parser_create();

function notation_handler($parser, $notationName, $base, $systemId, $publicId) {
  echo "Notation: $notationName";
  if ($systemId) {
    echo ", System ID: $systemId";
  }
  if ($publicId) {
    echo ", Public ID: $publicId";
  }
  echo "\n";
}

xml_set_notation_decl_handler($parser, 'notation_handler');

// ... rest of your XML parsing code

xml_parser_free($parser);
?>

This example simply prints out information about encountered notation declarations for demonstration purposes.

Use Cases

• Customizing notation handling for specific data types.
• Registering notations for later processing (not currently supported by PHP's XML functions).
• Validating notation declarations to ensure they comply with your application's requirements.

• If you do need to use external entities, be very cautious about the source of the data and take appropriate security measures, such as validating the content and using a whitelist of trusted URLs.
• xml_set_notation_decl_handler is not commonly used in modern PHP development because external entity processing can be a security risk. It's generally recommended to avoid using external entities unless absolutely necessary.

---

Simple Validation

This example showcases validating the notation name to ensure it starts with a specific prefix:

<?php
$parser = xml_parser_create();

function validate_notation_handler($parser, $notationName, $base, $systemId, $publicId) {
  if (strpos($notationName, 'MY_PREFIX_') !== 0) {
    echo "Error: Notation name '$notationName' must start with 'MY_PREFIX_'\n";
  }
  // ... (rest of your logic for handling valid notations)
}

xml_set_notation_decl_handler($parser, 'validate_notation_handler');

// ... rest of your XML parsing code

xml_parser_free($parser);
?>

Ignoring Unnecessary Notations

This example demonstrates ignoring notations that you're not interested in processing:

<?php
$parser = xml_parser_create();

$interestingNotations = ['notation1', 'notation2'];

function ignore_unwanted_handler($parser, $notationName, $base, $systemId, $publicId) {
  global $interestingNotations;
  if (!in_array($notationName, $interestingNotations)) {
    return; // Skip processing for uninteresting notations
  }
  // ... (your logic for handling the specific notations in $interestingNotations)
}

xml_set_notation_decl_handler($parser, 'ignore_unwanted_handler');

// ... rest of your XML parsing code

xml_parser_free($parser);
?>

• Consider alternative approaches (like whitelisting trusted URLs) for handling external data if possible.
• Exercise caution when using external entities due to potential security vulnerabilities.
• These are simplified examples for demonstration purposes.

---

1. Filter Out External Entities
   

   • If you don't require processing external data associated with notations, the safest approach is to disable external entity processing altogether. You can achieve this using the xml_parser_set_option function:

   xml_parser_set_option($parser, XML_OPTION_EXTERNAL_ENTITIES, FALSE);
   

   This prevents the parser from fetching or processing any external data linked through notations.

2. • If you must use external entities, implement a whitelist mechanism to restrict the URLs that the parser can access for notation data. This can involve:
     • Maintaining a list of approved URLs.
     • Validating the systemId passed to the notation handler function against the whitelist before processing the external data.
     • Consider using a library like parboiled/parser that offers more control over external entity handling.

3. Alternative Data Sources
   

   • Explore alternative ways to provide the data associated with notations without relying on external entities. This could involve:
     • Including the data directly within the XML document (if feasible).
     • Using a separate, secure mechanism to retrieve the data based on information from the notation declaration (e.g., storing data in a database and referencing it by ID in the notation).